Cloud Star Tricky Trainers Soft & Chewy Dog Training Treats 5 oz. Bag, Liver Flavor, Low Calorie Behavior Aid with 130 treats

I had originally bought this product back in 2022-2023 and i'd be lying if i said the quality has gone down. I saw a review saying they changed the formula and the texture was off but unless my other bag was just stale, these feel super similar, softer if anything! They cut super easily, they have never given my dog a stomach ache+ She absolutely loves them! Some complain about the smell but i prefer it, it helps my dog focus on training and the smell left on your hands goes away after 2-3 washes so it's not a big deal. The one thing i do wish they had was an option to buy in bulk for a slightly cheaper price haha. Or just a larger size bag because it feels like i'm going through so much so quickly since i'm currently training my dog hahaOverall super good quality, they last a while, they're not super expensive and they look like kibble so its easy for me to mix her food in a ziplock bag with them so they get the smell! lmao

These are amazing little treats and my chihuahua loves them, she gets one every time she goes out to potty and now when we come back in she will just set down in front of me and look at me until I give her 1 and she loves them.

If my dogs could give the review they would give it 10 stars! Need I say more?

I wish they had less ingredients. It’s a good size bag and my pup enjoys them.

I don’t use these for training I use them as regular treats so I don’t have to worry about how many extra calories I’m feeding my dogs throughout the day. They’re perfect for just a little “good boy” treat

Dog is 13 and been eating them as a treat after walk all along. She loves them and never any issues.

Just bought for new puppy currently only 4 lbs--she loves them and small enough she can chew. Bought because of the low calories allowing more treats.

My dog is picky about her treats, but she likes these. They are nice and small.